Author: Model Aviation
Edition: Model Aviation - 2004/08
Page Numbers: 167,168,169,170,171,172
,
,
,
,
,

Final Vote Results - 2004/08

Executive Council

  • EC-05-1: To move the Scale Helicopter Rules to the Helicopter section. EVP: Y; I: DNV; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: N; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: DNV; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 1; PASS

Outdoor Free Flight

  • OFF-05-2: Events 160 & 161. Change the current battery rules. EVP: DNV; I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: N; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 1; PASS
  • OFF-05-3: Events 160 & 161. Delete category classifications I, II, and III. EVP: DNV; I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: N; YES: 9; NO: 1; PASS

Indoor Free Flight

  • IND-05-1: Reclassify FAI Indoor EZB Model (F1L #217) official. I: Y; II: DNV; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS

Control Line General

  • CLG-05-1CP1: To clarify and limit allowed control methods. CL SPEED: Y; CL CARRIER: Y; CL RACING: Y; CL AEROBATICS: Y; CL COMBAT: Y; YES: 5; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLG-05-2: Event #332, page 66. Change engine displacement to metric equivalent. CL SPEED: Y; CL CARRIER: Y; CL RACING: N; CL AEROBATICS: Y; CL COMBAT: Y; YES: 4; NO: 1; PASS
  • CLG-05-3: Event #332. Reduce fuel tank capacity. CL SPEED: Y; CL CARRIER: Y; CL RACING: N; CL AEROBATICS: Y; CL COMBAT: Y; YES: 4; NO: 1; PASS

Control Line Speed

  • CLS-05-3: 1/2A Speed Events. Introduce standard 10% nitro fuel. EVP: NO REP; I: Y; II: Y; III: N; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: N; IX: N; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 7; NO: 3; PASS
  • CLS-05-5: Make 21 Proto an official event. EVP: NO REP; I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLS-05-8: Page 37, paragraph 11. Change standard timing equipment. EVP: NO REP; I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLS-05-9: Page 38, paragraph 18. Standardize all speed classes to a 15 foot maximum flight elevation. EVP: NO REP; I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: N; VIII: Y; IX: N; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 8; NO: 2; PASS

Control Line Aerobatics

  • CLA-05-1: Four Leaf Clover, paragraph 13:14. 38 degree elevation angle needs to be 42 degrees. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLA-05-2: CL Precision Aerobatics Model Requirements, Paragraph 2. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLA-05-3: CL Precision Aerobatics rule 2.3. National identification. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLA-05-4: Replace CL Precision Aerobatics Judges procedures with Judges Guide. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLA-05-8: Events 322, 323, 324, 325, 326. Optimize strength of standard CL sizes. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: Y; XI: N; YES: 8; NO: 1; PASS

Control Line Racing

  • CLR-05-1: Make Class II Mouse an official event. I: NO REP; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS

Control Line Navy Carrier

  • CLC-05-1: #321 Profile Carrier. Exempt 4-stroke engines from front intake requirement. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: DNV; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS

Control Line Combat

  • CLB-05-2: Event #328. Change allowed material for streamers. I: Y; II: DNV; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: DNV; XI: Y; YES: 8; NO: 0; PASS
  • CLB-05-3: Event #328. Change wording for pilot actions in the event of a line tangle. I: Y; II: DNV; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: N; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: DNV; XI: Y; YES: 7; NO: 1; PASS
  • CLB-05-4: Event #328. Allows CD to adjust size of safety circle to match field conditions. I: Y; II: DNV; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: N; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: DNV; XI: Y; YES: 7; NO: 1; PASS
  • CLB-05-5: Event #328. Deletes portion of paragraph 11.1. I: Y; II: DNV; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: DNV; XI: N; YES: 7; NO: 1; PASS
  • CLB-05-7: 1/2A Combat. Add new paragraph: Optional Equipment/Specifications. I: Y; II: DNV; III: Y; IV: Y; V: Y; VI: Y; VII: N; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: DNV; XI: Y; YES: 7; NO: 1; PASS

Radio Control Pylon Racing

  • RCR-05-1: Event #424. Add limitations to construction materials. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: Y; V: N; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: N; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 9; NO: 2; PASS
  • RCR-05-2: Event #424. Add approved engine list to rulebook. I: N; II: N; III: Y; IV: Y; V: N; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: Y; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 8; NO: 3; PASS
  • RCR-05-3: Add new provisional event, "Formula 1 Sport." I: N; II: Y; III: Y; IV: N; V: N; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: N; X: N; XI: Y; YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL

Radio Control Aerobatics

  • RCA-05-1: Page 72, 14. Flight Pattern and Maneuvering Aero. Clarify entering and exiting the box. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-2: Clean up no longer applicable, outdated or mismatched components of rulebook. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-03 CP1: Correct a deficiency regarding use of poles and lines at certain contests. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-4: AMA Judges Guide, page 78, Spins. Add subparagraph to correct misunderstandings. YES: 10; NO: 1; PASS
  • RCA-05-5: Page 82 and 86. Implement non-judged Takeoffs and Landings. YES: 8; NO: 3; PASS
  • RCA-05-6: 404 Masters Class. Replacement schedule. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-7: Allow contestants to use any AMA-legal airplane in Sportsman Class at the discretion of CD. YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL
  • RCA-05-8: Paragraph 8.2.3. Eliminate forced advancement of those who can't attain expertise due to age or skill level limitations. YES: 8; NO: 3; PASS
  • RCA-05-9: Paragraph 8.2.1. Insert new wording. YES: 5; NO: 6; FAIL
  • RCA-05-10: Horizontal Rolls. Correction of mistakes. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-12: Page 86. Takeoff Downgrades. Eliminate confusion about takeoff and centering. YES: 4; NO: 7; FAIL
  • RCA-05-13: Insert in Section E Description of Maneuvers. Clarify definition. YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL
  • RCA-05-14: Page 78. Definition of Spins. The drift of a spin may leave the aerobatic box without penalty. YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL
  • RCA-05-15: Page 78. Definition of Spins. The stall before the spin need not be preceded by a complete stop of forward motion. YES: 8; NO: 3; PASS
  • RCA-05-16: Paragraph 4.4.1. Eliminate requirement to restrict Sportsman competitors to fixed gear only. YES: 9; NO: 2; PASS
  • RCA-05-17: Intermediate (402). Add 2 maneuvers. YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL
  • RCA-05-18: Straight and Level Flight. Add definition. YES: 8; NO: 3; PASS
  • RCA-05-19: Page 78. Spins. Add to definition. YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL
  • RCA-05-23: 19. F1A Pattern Maneuvers. Noise rule. YES: 10; NO: 1; PASS

Radio Control Aerobatics (continued)

  • RCA-05-25: Add fifth class, Intermediate, to existing four classes. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-26: 3.3 Open Events. Add rule requiring all unknown sequences to be put together using the Catalog of Legal Unknown Figures for each class. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-27: 5. Proof of Scale. Keep Scale Aerobatics aircraft closer to scale. YES: 9; NO: 2; PASS
  • RCA-05-28: 6. Achievement Award patches. Add Intermediate Class. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-29: 8. Competition Classes. Add Intermediate Class. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-30: 10. Official Flights. Require contestants to carry enough fuel on board for an entire competition round. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-31: 12. Aerobatic Box. Remove rules Aerobatic Box, 12.1–12.7 from General rules. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-32: 16. Flight Pattern. Change the "world zones" to "area" in rule 16.4. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-33: 17. Four Minute Freestyle. Completely change the scoring and judging criteria for four minute Freestyle. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-34: 1. Preface. Make all references to gender in document both male and female. YES: 9; NO: 2; PASS
  • RCA-05-35: 2. FAI Aerobatic Catalog. All Scale Aerobatic K factors are same as FAI. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-36: 3. Rules. Show change in Aerobatic box size and add Intermediate to out-of-box penalty. YES: 10; NO: 1; PASS
  • RCA-05-37: 4. Positioning. Add a positioning score to the sequence. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-38: 4.1 Scale Aerobatic Box. Make Scale Aerobatic Box more in line with the current IAC and CIVA. YES: 10; NO: 1; PASS
  • RCA-05-39: 4.2 Scale Aerobatic Zones through 4.2.2 Side Zone. Eliminate references to zones and figure centers. YES: 10; NO: 1; PASS
  • RCA-05-40: 6.3 Zero. Correct the reasons for giving zeros for omitting or adding a figure in a sequence. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-41: 8.6 Family 6: Tailslide. Eliminate "cheat" of 10 degrees. YES: 11; NO: 0; PASS
  • RCA-05-43: Proposing Indoor R/C Aerobatics be accepted as a new AMA Event. YES: 6; NO: 5; FAIL

Radio Control Helicopter

  • RCH-05-1: 28.6.1 Class 1. To change pilot position to the same as Class II so maneuvers can be seen and for safety. YES: 10; NO: 1; PASS

Radio Control Soaring

  • SO-05-2: Event #460. Eliminate the prohibition of landing arrestor devices. YES: 7; NO: 3; PASS
  • SO-05-4: Establish rules and safety standards for RC Slope Soaring Combat. YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • SO-05-5: Add new event: Nostalgia Sailplanes. YES: 9; NO: 1; PASS

Radio Control Scale

  • SCA-05-1: CL Precision Scale Pull Test Table. Word correction. YES: 8; NO: 2; PASS
  • SCA-05-2: CL Fun Scale proposed as a new event. YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • SCA-05-04 CP1: Event #518. Change the order of two flight maneuvers. Section 9 Scale Flight Plan and 14 Judging guidelines. YES: 9; NO: 1; PASS
  • SCA-05-5: Event #521. No score reduction for lack of retracts of profile CL scale model. YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • SCA-05-6: Events 511, 512, 513, 515, 520, 522. To allow for indoor flying of RC scale models. YES: 8; NO: 2; PASS
  • SCA-05-7: Indoor Electric R/C Scale (Provisional). New event. YES: 6; NO: 4; PASS
  • SCA-05-8: Event #517. Reduce number of mandatory maneuvers and eliminate "maintain straight attitude" from maneuver list. YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • SCA-05-9: Event #517. Correct current wording. YES: 9; NO: 1; PASS
  • SCA-05-11: Event #517. Include hi-start and hand tow as launch options. YES: 10; NO: 0; PASS
  • SCA-05-12: Provide a common worksheet for static judging of CL and RC Sport Scale. YES: 3; NO: 7; FAIL

Final Vote Results (continued)

Radio Control Combat

  • RCC-05-3: Event #750. Change event rules to match current RCCA rules. I: Y; II: Y; III: Y; IV: DNV; V: N; VI: Y; VII: Y; VIII: Y; IX: NO REP; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 8; NO: 1; PASS
  • RCC-05-8: Event #750. Change aircraft rules regarding dimensions and maximum power limits. I: N; II: N; III: N; IV: DNV; V: Y; VI: N; VII: Y; VIII: N; IX: NO REP; X: N; XI: N; YES: 2; NO: 7; FAIL

Electric

  • ELC-05-1: RC Electric 1/2A Elexaco. Restricted to a specific power package assures equity. I: Y; II: N; III: DNV; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: DNV; VIII: DNV; IX: DNV; X: Y; XI: Y; YES: 5; NO: 1; PASS
  • ELC-05-2: Page 186, section 4.21. Change the battery designation from a capacity designation to physical size designation. I: Y; II: Y; III: DNV; IV: Y; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: DNV; VIII: DNV; IX: DNV; X: Y; XI: N; YES: 5; NO: 1; PASS
  • ELC-05-3: New event: 629 Open Class Electric Indoor Duration. I: Y; II: Y; III: DNV; IV: N; V: DNV; VI: Y; VII: DNV; VIII: DNV; IX: DNV; X: Y; XI: N; YES: 4; NO: 2; PASS

Special Events

  • SEB-05-2: Event #705. Change 8.4.3. Timed Flight wording.
  • INDOOR: ABSTAIN
  • CL SPEED: Y
  • CL CARRIER: DNV
  • CL RACING: Y
  • CL AEROBATICS: Y
  • CL COMBAT: Y
  • FREE FLIGHT: N
  • SCALE: Y
  • ELECTRIC: Y
  • AEROBATICS: Y
  • HELICOPTER: Y
  • RC PYLON RACING: Y
  • RC SOARING: Y
  • RC COMBAT: Y
  • CB CHAIR: N
  • YES: 11; NO: 3; PASS

Transcribed from original scans by AI. Minor OCR errors may remain.